The Healing of Memories

The ancient desert fathers observed that the battle for the heart is waged in the mind. St. Augustine would add that the mind has a stomach, that is, the memory. This means that the battle for the heart is waged also where we digest our experiences, feelings and thoughts, that is, in the memory. Anyone who attempts to deal with his own memory in prayer, as did Augustine in his Confessions or Teresa de Jesus in her Life, soon discovers that both how we digest our experiences and the judgments we make because of this bad digestion is in great need of healing.
Indeed, there are deadly cancers at work in this stomach of the mind that constantly threaten and undermine a soul's spiritual health. Our battle is against malignant judgments, emotional tumors, and malignant fantasies that poison not only bodily health, but the soul itself. All of these things live in our memory and if unaddressed, can easily rob us of hope. And the heart needs hope - because "in this world there are troubles," and so we must take heart because, as the Word of the Father constantly reminds us, "I have overcome the world" (John 16:33).
How does God heal the memories and what does it look like from the standpoint of an individual's experience? St. Teresa describes it in terms of the unfolding of her life of prayer into full maturity. St. John of the Cross building on St. Augustine describes it in terms of the virtue of hope. St. Augustine himself also sees this healing and purification in terms of hope, but he focuses on the soul's vision of the truly beautiful. It is the beauty of God that heals memories and restores the hope that we need for living the Christian life.
In Augustine's Confessions, memory is not simply the power to recall life-events or important relationships. It has to do with one's very awareness of themselves. He says that memory is a kind of stomach of the mind, the place where all our life experiences are digested to become part of who we are. The memory is also a dwelling place of God in the soul. Not contained by any specific memory, He is present in our memory, present to things we are able to recall and to other things that are lost to our memory, things that we have done and things that we have failed to do. He is present even to our sins and the wounds that sin causes. This Divine Presence, moreover, is not aloof or disinterested in how we understand ourselves and the world, but always at work with a certain kindly benevolence that testifies to the truth that we need inorder to thrive. For St. Augustine, this Divine Presence holds together all that memory contains with the power to purify and heal, and, thus, he engages the Word made Flesh in a conversatio morum, that is, in a holy conversation about his whole manner of life, with great hope.
St. Augustine asks the Lord for healing. It is important to notice that he requests this of the "Beauty ever ancient, ever new." The dynamic of beauty evokes eros, the deep desire of heart that drives us out of what is familiar and comfortable to take possession of something, someone totally other than us. While we may remember many different kinds of beauty and many different experiences of it, beyond them all is another Beauty that stands behind all of these memories with the power to heal them and make them holy. It is for this beauty that we ought to long, but we are haunted by memories of lesser things that we longed for in ways we should not have. Yet even these things brought us out of ourselves, even if only partially and in broken ways. The judgments, emotions and thoughts that come from our broken pursuits may haunt us and hold us back, but when we humbly ask, God's own beauty can shine through them so that instead of a prison, they become a threshold to freedom. The beautiful, then, opens up our memory to mysteries beyond itself, mysteries that take us out of ourselves and implicate us in wonders that enrich us and can make us fruitful.
So many are afraid to ask for and allow the splendor of the truth to shine on their memories. The truly beautiful, because it has the power to free us from our evil judgments, indeed from our self-occupation, is terrifying. Moreover, it is this terror that is so healing to a soul that finds it. We know that the beauty of the Truth Himself works this way on us in this way because we have already expereinced Him working through others in this way in our lives. I mean, that experience of being so overcome by the beauty of another that one falls in love. While it can always be betrayed, the joy of falling in love with another and of being moved to draw close to them implies that you have seen the truth of who they are and the splendor of that truth has made a call upon your existence. One cannot live the same way again once he has seen that beauty. What I am saying is that there is a certain analogy between the beauty of the beloved that stirred your love and the ever greater and more wonderful Beauty of the Truth Himself who lives in you. The dynamism of the passing beauty of one's beloved is a sign that points to the dynamism of Divine Beauty - a power that heals and transforms one's whole existence in an even more wonderful way.
Let me press this analogy a little further. Is it not true that when we see the beauty of the beloved, a certain terror grips our hearts? When the call of the truly beautiful is made over one's heart, a twofold realization strikes all at once. One feels drawn to take possession but at the same time knows at a very deep level that by taking possession, life will never be the same. Before one is fruitful, life is marked by a certain comfort and familiarity, even if it feels empty and lonely. The beautiful promises a new communion filled with meaning, a new purpose, a whole new life. To have the courage to embrace this newness, to take the risk, this means to leave behind what is comfortable and convenient, and to press forward into a mystery the memory does not yet know. To fail to take this risk means to choose forever to live a diminished existence, a life filled with "should haves" and "could haves," the empty life of regret. To see, to behold, to contemplate what is truly beautiful is to step on the royal road of freedom, the only pathway that allows a man or woman to realize the greatness to which one is called. My argument is that if this is true even for frailty of human love, it is true in a much fuller and more complete sense with the love of God, the beauty that can heal even our most broken and painful memories.
This mystery is expressed in the procession of the bride to the sanctuary in the matrimonial liturgy. The veiled beauty of the bride already evokes the eros of the bridegroom as she processes to the altar. The wedding dress is (believe it or not) a sacramental, that is a sign of an ecclesial, mystical reality. The analogy of the Great Mystery referred to in Ephesians 5 comes into play. The Church is also veiled and her wedding dress is all the works of mercy, all the hidden sacrifices of love performed in faith, unseen by the world, but known by Christ. The wedding procession is meant to evoke among the faithful a certain awe and trembling before good works of the Church - because these works are more than human. The good works of the Church witnessed to by her countless saints are truly beautiful and disclose the beauty of the Bride as she approaches the Bridegroom - He who waits for her at the end of time. Just as the veil of the bride discloses her beauty before the bridegroom, the Church's procession through human history draws the devotion of Christ Himself. As Christ takes possession of the Church, the more fruitful she becomes, the more transformed the whole cosmos into a new heavens and earth.
What is true ecclesially and cosmically in creation is also true in the spiritual life of the soul, in its very memory. The Truth Himself wants to transform our memories so that instead of being obstacles, they might be fountains of grace not only for ourselves but for all those entrusted to us. It is a good work to submit our memories to Christ in prayer through an examination of our lives and for an examination of how we live each day. When we do this out of devotion to the Lord, He draws near to us and makes even our mistakes and failures into mysteries that glorify the Father.
St. Augustine, on this score, is judicious. When it comes to the spiritual life, desiderium or eros is fundamental. This is so fundamental a part of human experience that to ignore it is certain disaster. He does not believe in extinguishing this desire of the heart, this yearning for the truly beautiful. He wants to baptize it. That is, he wants Christ to become the One for whom his heart longs.
Here is the challenge: Augustine knows from his own bitter experience that the human heart is given to the beauty of things that pass away, but also that none of these things is enough for it. This is a fatal disorder - because, in his worldview, you "become" so to speak what you "love." Thus, as he unfolds the healing of memory, he will discuss this disorder as concupiscence - concupiscentia carnis, concupiscentia oculorum, et ambitione saeculi from 1 John 2:16. In John's letter, this whole mystery comes from the world, and by world, he means an experience of time, space, social and cosmic forces without any relation to God. When John writes about the world, he does not mean creation, that is the world as contemplated in relationship to the creator, but instead as the experience of the profane absent the organizing principle of the sacred.
Our memories are wounded because under concupiscence we do not see reality rightly. When the profane, that is all that is other than God, is not experienced as something ordered by and for holiness, the broken memory of it wounds, blinds and weakens eros. We make judgments that threaten our integrity, how to relate to the world, and how to relate to God whenever we behold or expereince any part of creation as seperate from God. Thus, the judgements we make based experience diseased by such concupiscence can only be erroneous, only partially true, if true at all.
Such judgments live in our broken memories, or better, our memories of an experience of the world broken off from God. Under the weight of such memories, this movement toward the beautiful in our hearts is shattered into proclivities toward lesser kinds of beauty to replace our need for God's beauty. Whenever these are acted upon, or even when someone driven by these things acts against us, new wounds of sin are added to the memory. If we are ever to see rightly, we need to deal with these, submit these to the love of God for healing, for purification, for freedom from the false judgments that bind us into habit patterns of sin..
So often have we sinned or have others sinned against us that our memories are filled with these judgments. The more unconscious and unexamined these judgments, the more they drive us. In fact, as we learn to pray in the face of sinful memories and false judgments, we do not at first feel like we are getting better. Instead, our awareness of how broken we are becomes more acute. We feel like we are getting worse. But this is only a feeling. This is where St. Augustine invites us to do some hard work - or rather, to allow God to do some hard work in us, work that will require his endurance and perseverance to unfold in us. After he came to "know" the Lord by a lived faith, St. Augustine sought His presence in his memory through prayer. This means, he spent time examining his memory for the things he did and failed to do, and even more for the ways God was present to him and at work in him, even when he was far from God. What he finds in prayer is the source of delight:
How widely I have ranged through my memory seeking you, Lord, and I have not found you outside it; for I have discovered nothing about you that I did not remember from the time I learned to know you. From that time when I learned about you I have never forgotten you, because wherever I have found truth I have found my God who is absolute Truth, and once I had learned that I did not forget it. That is why you have dwelt in my memory ever since I learned to know you, and it is there that I find you when I remember and delight in you. These are my holy delights, and they are your gift to me, for in your mercy you look graciously upon my poverty. Book X, chptr 24. 35 Lucas Verheijen and J.J. O'Donnell, Green Bay: Aquinas Institute (2023) 231.
Notice that St. Augustine finds poverty in his memory (and this is in his memory as a baptized Christian). He is describing the emptiness caused by sin in his life. But in finding his poverty, he makes an even more important discovery. Namely, this poverty is not something apart from God. Rather, his emptiness, his wound is the object of divine action, "in your mercy you look graciously upon my poverty."
Our interior poverty is the object of God's own gracious contemplation. In other words, God sees something beautiful in Augustine, not despite, but because of his poverty. God is drawn to it and wants to do something about it. So also in our memories of sin, of things that were done to us and things that we have done or failed to do, God is already looking graciously to heal us. Beauty Himself is drawn to our plight and longs to act, and in fact is already acting even as you read these words. To believe this Truth is to make oneself vulnerable to his saving action, to allow His Light to shine in our memory anew so that He might heal our memories and open the eyes of our hearts to the great hope that He has in store for us.
The saving truth, the truth we need to really live, this is not a truth that we intellectually assent to, although even this might be a first step. Instead, it is a truth that shows us the uncreated Beauty that has chosen to dwell in us and who is gazing on us, and in whose gaze we are being made beautiful, in, through and with all our memories, even the broken and difficult ones. In other words, it is a when the Truth dawns on us in true Beauty that evil judgments are dispelled and purified. The more our judgments are purified by the truth, the greater the freedom and intensity of life we enjoy. Life becomes more meaningful.
St. Augustine approach to this kind of spiritual healing does not imply that bad memories magically disappear or that old temptations do not sometimes haunt us or even that we do not feel ever heartache and sorrow as we grow in holiness. These memories can be, at times, the cause of great trials and call for perseverance. St. Augustine's teaching suggests that in the very face of these painful realities, God is giving us the grace to persevere in faith. The bad memories do not define us or limit how we respond to the demands of love in our lives when we believe even more in the beautiful things that God is accomplishing in us. In this life, in fact, we constantly confront new areas that we did not know are in need of healing, but nonetheless are being healed. And we confront these wounds with faith in the goodness of God. Put differently, in this life, the evil things that we have done and that have been done to us yet live in our memories, but they remain in a state of being healed, being transformed in light of a new judgment of heart, one that is possible because the light of God's truth has shown on us and set us free.
This is why St. Thomas teaches that sins confessed in the Sacrament of Penance are the very matter of the sacrament, that is these sinful acts that live in our memories are transformed by grace into new manifestations of His saving power in our lives. Painful as they are, we do not remember them the same way. Their memory is changed so that by faith we can choose to see even within our sins the wonderful mystery of God making all things new. Instead of disposing us away from what is sacred and holy, these same wounds are now transformed into icons of mercy, into memories through which the love of God shines into our lives.
This is the grace of repentance. It comes at the price of compunction, holy tears. It comes only by grace, that is in the form of a sheer gift from God rather than something we sieze for ourselves or accomplish on our own. When we repent, when we see what has happened or what we have done in the light of God's truth, we come to participate in God's judgment about sin, the world and his own righteousness. We were once bound to the evil that we did or was done to us, but now we are bound to the love of God, and his beauty is making us fruitful in new and every more wonderful ways.
The heart is immortal and so needs immortal beauty, the only Beauty that does not pass away. This Beauty is at work in the Christian memory. This means first of all the memory of each baptized soul - God's radiance shines in the gut of mind to heal the cancers of despair that threaten the heart. Baptized into the Radiant One, the Christian life is about the triumph of the Light that shines in the darkness.
Everytime we struggle against resentment, anxiety or selfishness, we taste once again the unfolding of this victory in space and time, in the exigencies of our own personal existence. As we persevere in the trials caused by the wounds of sin, the bad memories that haunt our hearts, we realize over and over the triumph of grace in ever new and unexpected ways. Specifically, the trial is to believe in the face of our disbelief, to live by hope when it seems against all hope, to choose put love where love seems absent.
Such a choice involves gently and patiently renouncing and surrendering to God all the evil thoughts, feelings, and emotions that come up in our memory until one finds the freedom to know and do God's will. Kept afloat by this hope, anchored in it, we find the courage to open our eyes to new possibilities, to the wonder of God's plan - a plan that is ever so much more than we can ever imagine or understand. For Augustine, this is the very purpose of this life we have been given to live -- to learn to open the eyes of our hearts. Painful memories that no longer dispose us to keep our eyes shut instead allow our gaze to behold how much God love us, these memories have been transformed into something new. In them lives the courage to act with a power that the world is longing to know.


Beautiful
Thank you for this reflection. "It [memory] has to do with one's very awareness of themselves." This phrase reminds me of gently holding my awareness on the attitude of my heart, as I behold Him in my heart, especially the hurting and restless parts. Your reflection helped me see how in prayer my awareness of myself, my memory, is transformed into something more beautiful than i can yet imagine. Thank you.